Rating: 3.5 out of 5.

With pirates, a hunt for treasure and plenty of nautical mischief, the world premiere of new Australian musical Silver Tongue is an unconventional adventure.

This is a re-imagining of Robert Louis Stevenson’s Treasure Island, but not as audiences might expect. An off-beat, queer take on the classic adventure, co-writers Miranda Middleton and Jacob Parker describe it as “a love letter to the queer people who have paved the way before us, and a safe port in a storm for generations to come.”

Directed by Richard Carroll, this production brings the naughty into nautical. Long John Silver becomes the female Silver Tongue (Billie Palin), and while there is romance on the high seas, this is certainly not a traditional love story. There’s humour in the innuendo, and there’s a lot of it.

Where the musical really excels is in its rollicking, multi-instrumental performances, led by Music Director Victoria Falconer. With on-stage piano, cello, accordion, violin, and saxophone, the music moves from sea shanties to camp cabaret numbers.

Composer Alec Steedman’s original music draws on folk influences and orchestral sound, creating music he describes as “expansive, dramatic, heartfelt, and at times utterly stupid”. Steedman was recently nominated for a Sydney Theatre Award for Best Musical Direction on a Musical for his work on Bright Star.

Theatrical ensemble performs a lively pirate-themed scene on a stage set with ropes, a piano, and wooden tables.
Photography by John McCrae

Marty Alix (Jim) delivers a lovely, softer moment with ‘Write My Story’ before showcasing his powerhouse vocals, while Natalie Abbott (Dick), whose voice is a joy, shines in the hilarious cabaret number ‘Land Hoe’ is performed with co-stars Tana Laga’aia (Hands) and Shannen Alyce Quan (Livesey). Abbott was most recently seen in Rebel Wilson’s The Deb, and after hearing her vocals, it’s hard not to wish there were more songs dedicated to showcasing them.

Jack Green commands the stage, especially in the role of the not-so-humble Squire. His performance in ‘Maroon Inn’ is an audience favourite as the fantasy goes into the absurd, most noticeably with Sam Hernandez’s costume design featuring beluga whales in tutus.

Hailley Hunt’s set design makes clever use of the theatre space, with performers climbing ropes along the walls and sheets helping create a world of seafaring adventure, while a little shadow play adds to the visual storytelling.

Daniel Herten’s sound design is once again worth highlighting. The surround sound of drums, storm and thunder creates an atmospheric theatrical foreplay, complemented by mist and low lighting. The flashes of lightning, however, felt a little overdone, at times so blinding that audience members were forced to look away.

Silver Tongue is swashbuckling fun. Embrace the silly in this wild voyage.

AT A GLANCE

ProductionHayes Theatre Co
VenueHayes Theatre
LocationPotts Point, Sydney
DatesSeason closes 19 Dec 2026
Runtime100 minutes (no interval)
GenreMusical, Comedy
Best forMusical theatre fans after a cheeky, camp night of high-seas mischief
🍴 Pre-showBar Sopra
🍷 NightcapProhibition Gin, Field Blend Shiraz
A rule-breaking pour for a rule-breaking crew.
Rating3.5 stars
Photography by John McCrae

Discover more from Bacchus at the Theatre

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

Trending

Have a show to review, a table to book or a bottle to pour?
We’d love to hear from you. Get in touch